Yesterday, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) issued a very comprehensive report on Medicare Advantage plans.I found the following to be an especially important finding:"In 2007, CBO estimates the average payments to such plans [MA] is 12% above traditional FFS costs. The difference is larger for private fee-for-service plans: According to estimates by the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission
Read full post »
Browse » Home » Archives for June 2007
"Mid-Atlantic Convergence"--The European Government-Run Health Care Systems Are Coming Our Way!
One of the themes I have often heard in international meetings on the topic of health insurance is the term, "Mid-Atlantic Convergence."That is, our system may be gravitating to look more like those in Europe and theirs maybe moving more toward ours.One of the people I often see at these meetings is Bill Boyles, publisher of Health Market Survey and Consumer-Driven Care.Today, I have asked Bill
Read full post »
The Cost to Administer Medicare Versus the Cost to Administer Private Health Plans--The Difference Isn't Anything Close to 25%
Those that favor a single-payer government-run health care system have been reenergized by the Michael Moore movie, "Sicko."One of their contentions I keep hearing is that we could save 25% by getting rid of private health insurance plans and creating one big government-run plan. They point to Medicare's expense factor of 2.9% as evidence.The private health insurance plans have much higher
Read full post »
"AMA Takes on Retail Clinics"--Oh Come On!
That was the headline in today's Chicago Tribune.The American Medical Association (AMA) is having their annual meeting in Chicago and is considering opposing the opening of in-store health care clinics in places like Wal-Mart and Walgreen drug stores.The docs are arguing that this new phenomenon in health care, that would give consumers a low-cost and quick access to very basic medical care,
Read full post »
A Canadian-Style Health Care System--How Would We Get From Here to There?
The movie "Sicko" inevitably gets us talking about making over America's health care system into one that would resemble the single-payer government-run systems like those in Canada, Britain, France--or now even Cuba!I find the proposal a simplistic one.Having spent so much time in Europe and Canada working with health care policymakers and major stakeholders there, let me first tell you I have a
Read full post »
A Review of the Movie "Sicko"--Michael Moore Blew It!
Michael Moore's new movie, "Sicko," was supposed to be this great argument for a "single payer" government-run health care system.It turned out to be exactly the opposite because Moore overplayed his hand and did his argument more damage than good.The first half of the movie would have had anyone mad at the system--and for good reasons. It's real easy to find lots of examples of market stupidity
Read full post »
Will Medicare Advantage Payments Be Cut as Soon as 2008?
That's the question a poster asked today and it has been an issue on my mind. So I will address it here.First, CMS has already started the rate setting process for 2008 and will have it finalized by early September. While the Congress makes the rules and can do anything it wants, it would be very difficult to change the 2008 deal with the private sector after early September.The only way we would
Read full post »
Commercial Health Care Cost Trend—Finally Hitting Bottom?
Commercia health insurance cost trend peaked in 2003 when costs hit 13.9%. On the same basis, health care cost trend fell to 7.7% in 2006 (Source: Kaiser Family Foundation Survey).Will medical cost trend keep falling in 2007 or are we near the bottom?The health insurance business tends to benefit from falling trend rates. Employers and benefit consultants tend to look backward when health care
Read full post »
Leading Democratic Presidential Candidates Comment on Health Care This Week
Joe Paduda, over at Managed Care Matters, is attending the "Take Back America" conference in DC this week. Joe has been posting a review on his site of each of the Democratic candidates comments on health care.Comments include a review of Clinton, Edwards, Obama, and Richardson.
Read full post »
Cavalcade of Risk #28 is Up
Julie Ferguson, of Workers Comp Insider, hosts this week's "Cavalcade of Risk."This edition includes a couple of dozen of the best recent blog posts on the issue of managing risk.
Read full post »
Senator Max Baucus Is Crucial to the Health Insurance Industry's Continued Medicare Advantage Funding--But How Sympathetic Is He?
Everyone knows that House Ways and Means Subcommittee Chair Pete Stark is the Medicare Advantage program's biggest high-powered Congressional critic.The view of Medicare Advantage health plan payments, particularly for the controversial Private Fee For Service (PFFS) program, is more moderate in the Senate. Undoubtedly, the House Democrats will be more aggressive in the cuts they want than will
Read full post »
"Sicko"--Hate it All You Like But Don't Ignore It! The Best Response is to Satisfy the Customer!
Michael Moore's harsh critique, make that condemnation, of the health insurance industry is going to be hard to watch for those who have spent their careers in the business.The worst thing we can do is to rationalize it away as just another "single payer's" prescription for socialized health care.Thirty years ago, I was taught by the insurance company I worked for that the way to be profitable
Read full post »
Biggest Employers Propose Their Own Health Care Reform Plan––Moving Toward Individual-Based Benefits
The ERISA Industry Committee (ERIC) has proposed a far-reaching reform of not only the health insurance system but the employer-provided retirement system as well.They call for the movement of these important benefit plans from the workplace to individual ownership and responsibility.The group represents many of America's largest employers and covers 30 million people in their benefit plans.They
Read full post »
MedPAC Recommends a Reasonable Road Map For Reducing Private Medicare Advantage Payments--Plan Would Equalize Payments Over a Five-Year Period
The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC), the Congressional advisory group on Medicare payment issues, has sent a report to Congress recommending that the Congress structure future private Medicare plan payments in a way that eventually equalizes private plan and public plan costs.MedPAC said in its report that current Medicare Advantage reimbursement does not promote increased
Read full post »
Wall Street Comes to Washington--A Fascinating Discussion Between Wall Street Analysts and the Washington Health Policy Community
Paul Ginsburg, of the Center for Studying Health System Change, has been hosting a conference for 12 years where he brings some of the leading Wall Street analysts following the health care sector to Washington and puts them in a room with 400 Washington health policy people.The interchange, and the different perspectives, between the Wall Streeters and the Washington policy people is
Read full post »
Industry Trade Association Pledges to Halt Medicare Fee For Service Marketing Until Sales Abuses Are Cleaned Up--But Forgot to Mention One Thing
This from the June 15 AHP health insurance trade association news release:"Taking a major step to give Medicare beneficiaries peace of mind, today seven of our member companies are making a pledge to voluntarily stop marketing non-group Medicare Advantage Private Fee For Service plans and to strengthen consumer protections by implementing now the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS)
Read full post »
You Can't Have the Medicare Advantage Private Fee-For-Service Training Wheels Forever
Actually, my point was that the industry's arguments to preserve private fee-for-service payments amounted to an appeal to preserve corporate welfare, not that the original PFFS program is corporate welfare, but I'll accept the gist of this story:APConsultant Favors Cuts to Medicare PlansThursday June 14, 3:06 pm ETBy Matthew Perrone, AP Business WriterConsultant Says Congress Should Limit
Read full post »
Wall Street Journal Sends Shockwaves Through the Health Insurance Markets With the Headline "Health Savings Plans Start to Falter"
It's the kind of headline I would have expected to see in the New York Times instead of the Wall Street Journal but there it was in Tuesday's edition.Vanessa Fuhrmans' article seems to have unleashed some pent-up frustration in the health benefits market on the subject of health savings accounts (HSAs) specifically and consumer-driven care generally. It is as if it represents a turning point for
Read full post »
Can We Control Health Care Costs Without Universal Coverage?
My good friend, Joe Paduda, over at his blog, "Managed Care Matters" has responded to my recent post: The Mandate Myth--Health Reform Plans Don't Have to Mandate Coverage to Work But They Do Have Be Affordable.Joe has made the point that it might be important to mandate coverage in order to prevent cost shifting. He is pointing out that unless we mandate that everyone is in the health care
Read full post »
Latest "Health Wonk Review" is Up
David Williams is hosting the latest edition of Health Wonk Review over at his site, "Health Business Blog."It is the bi-weekly compendium of some of the best posts in the health blog world!
Read full post »
Why Does Health Insurance Cost So Much in New England?
I guess the easy answer is because health care itself costs so much in New England.As I travel around the country, I continue to hear that plan sponsors and insurers are all frustrated by the comparatively high health care (and insurance) costs in New England. For example, according to CMS, health care spending for Massachusetts residents exceed the national average by more than $1,500, or 33% in
Read full post »
McCain to Propose a Health Care Reform Plan--Both Democrats and Republicans Becoming Predictable on Health Care
Republican presidential candidate Senator John McCain said this weekend that he is working on a health care reform proposal. He gave no time for its release but did mention a number of components:His plan will not include tax increases.It will not include any coverage mandates--presumably individual or employer mandates.He would make greater use of health care information technology.It will
Read full post »
The Mandate Myth--Health Reform Plans Don't Have to Mandate Coverage to Work But They Do Have Be Affordable
As the presidential candidates, Republican and Democratic, begin to come forward with their health reform plans, a side debate is heating up about whether any meaningful health care reform plan has to have a mandate, individual or employer.The reasoning goes that for health care reform to work we need to get about everyone in the pool--both in order to solve the uninsured problem and to be able
Read full post »
Giuliani Set to Announce a Health Care Proposal--But He Has to Make it Affordable for Everyone
Republican presidential candidate Rudy Giuliani is set to announce a new health plan this summer that would provide incentives to shift private health insurance from the employer group model to the individual health insurance model, according to an article in Thursday's Wall Street Journal.Details are sketchy. We understand that it would still allow the traditional employer plans to continue, it
Read full post »
New Ideas in Medical Liability Reform: Health Courts
Today, our guest contributor is Brynna Pietz of Common Good. Common Good has been a leader in arguing that it isn't enough to simply cap medical malpractice damages and call it reform. Instead, they believe we need to fundamentally change the health care tort system to one that does a better job of more quickly compensating the injured patient--and perhaps more importantly--improving the quality
Read full post »
Barack Obama on Health Care Reform and the Insurance and Drug Industries--a Healthy Cynicism
Earlier this week I wondered why Hillary Clinton continues to try to isolate and demonize the insurance and pharmaceutical industry in her comments about health care reform: Hillary Clinton on Health Care--Trying the Divide and Conquer Strategy Once AgainI pointed out that you would think she would have learned from her failed divide and conquer tactics in 1994.It is interesting to contrast
Read full post »
Hillary Clinton on Health Care--Trying the Divide and Conquer Strategy Once Again
In Sunday's Democratic presidential debate, Hillary Clinton once again tried to isolate the insurance industry (as well as the pharmaceutical business) as a means to advance her health plan.On health care Senator Clinton said, "What's important, and what I learned in the previous effort is you've got to have the political will--a broad coalition of business and labor, doctors, nurses, hospitals..
Read full post »
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)